Should Bottled Water Be Taxed?

What is a Pigovian Tax?

What is an “externality”?

An externality occurs when a business, product, or activity creates a negative effect on others in a society, but not necessarily on itself. For example, pollution is an externality, for example. A government may impose a tax on non-compliant vehicles so their owners’ shoulder more of the cost of cleaning the air.

What does the word “Pigovian” mean?

The word is derived from a man’s name, Arthur Pigou. He was a British economist, and the practice of taxing things considered harmful was his brainchild. He developed the concept of externalities. He proposed that governments should intervene to correct these negative impacts by taxing harmful activity and using the revenue to correct the harm and improve society.

What does this have to do with plastic bottles?

The devastating impact of discarded plastic water bottles—a problem that can be eased with investments in water dispensing machines that harness and purify conventional tap water—is well documented. Here’s a brief statistical recap provided by earthday.org. 


  • People buy about 1,000,000 plastic bottles per minute. In the U.S., only about 23% are recycled. 

  • 32% of the 78 million tons of plastic packaging produced annually is left to flow into our oceans. This is the equivalent of pouring one garbage truck of plastic into the ocean every minute. By 2050, there could be more plastic in the world’s oceans than fish. 

  • When single-use plastics are sent to landfills, they can leak harmful pollutants into the watershed. 

  • Americans purchase about 50 billion water bottles per year, averaging about 13 bottles per month for every person in the U.S. That means by using a reusable water bottle, one person could save an average of 156 plastic bottles annually. 

  • The best way to curb single-use plastic pollution is to reduce your personal plastic consumption.

Is This Realistic?

The theory behind placing a Pigovian Tax on single-use plastic bottles is that companies that place their products in non-biodegradable packaging should pay a little more to help clean up the resulting environmental damage. There also is a belief that the resulting higher prices on bottled products might discourage consumers from buying them at all, leading to an increase in more environmentally friendly forms of refreshment. 


There has been no major push in the U.S. to enact such a tax. Pigovian Taxes on disposable plastics have been discussed in India, with no action taken so far. 


Natura Water is a leader in drinking water purification systems, offering water dispensing machines, sparkling water machines, and, in general, foodservice equipment quality water systems that can undo the waste inherent in single-use water bottles. Our water dispensing systems offer an endless supply of pure, fabulous-tasting, chilled still, chilled sparkling, and still ambient water. With zero plastic waste. 


Natura’s unique approach to “gourmet water” was first developed in Italy, where water, like wine, is considered an essential part of every meal. After passing the rigorous testing of discriminating European palates, Natura was ready for the U.S. and the rest of the world. For two decades, we’ve remained a leader in the category we helped create.


Need more information? Click here to download our case study or click here to schedule a meeting! 

Recent Posts

March 30, 2026
Should You Be Charging Guests for Water in 2026? In today’s evolving dining landscape, even the smallest details of the guest experience are under scrutiny—and increasingly, that includes water. What was once a simple, complimentary offering has transformed into a strategic decision point for restaurants. From still to sparkling, filtered to mineral-enhanced, water service has become an extension of a restaurant’s brand, values, and profitability. So in 2026, the question isn’t just can you charge for sparkling water—it’s should you? The Rise of Premium Water Service Across the industry, premium water programs have become more common. Guests are more accustomed than ever to curated beverage experiences, and that expectation now extends beyond wine and cocktails. At the same time, restaurants are facing continued pressure from: Rising supply and logistics costs Sustainability demands Tighter margins post-inflation cycles Bottled sparkling water, in particular, has become significantly more expensive due to transportation, packaging regulations, and environmental considerations. As a result, many operators are rethinking how water fits into both their guest experience and their bottom line. The Case for Charging 1. Cost Recovery Is No Longer Optional Margins remain tight in 2026. Charging for sparkling water helps offset real and rising costs—especially when compared to traditional bottled programs. 2. Guests Expect Customization Today’s diners are used to choice. Offering premium water—sparkling, chilled, filtered, or infused—aligns with broader personalization trends in hospitality. 3. Brand Positioning For upscale or experience-driven restaurants, premium water reinforces a commitment to quality. Just as guests pay more for craft cocktails or locally sourced ingredients, many see upgraded water as part of the experience. The Case Against Charging 1. Water Is Still Seen as a Basic Right Despite evolving expectations, many guests still believe water should be free—especially in the U.S. Charging can feel excessive if not handled carefully. 2. Perception of “Nickel-and-Diming” In an era where transparency matters more than ever, unexpected charges—even small ones—can negatively impact guest satisfaction and reviews. 3. Hospitality Matters Restaurants aren’t just selling food—they’re selling experience. If guests feel pressured or upsold on something fundamental, it can erode trust. The 2026 Approach: Balance and Transparency The most successful restaurants today are not choosing one side—they’re blending both. A modern best practice includes: Complimentary still or filtered tap water (clearly offered) Optional premium sparkling water as an upgrade Transparent pricing or inclusive service models Some operators are even adopting a flat per-table water fee (typically $1–$3 per guest), which includes unlimited still and sparkling water. This model simplifies service while remaining cost-effective compared to bottled alternatives. The key is clarity—guests are far more accepting of charges when they understand the value. How Natura Helps Restaurants Stay Competitive In 2026, operational efficiency and sustainability are just as important as guest experience—and this is where Natura systems stand out. By producing triple-filtered still and sparkling water on-site , restaurants can: Eliminate the cost and logistics of bottled water Reduce storage needs and waste Maintain consistent quality with every pour Improve sustainability metrics (a growing factor in guest decision-making) Instead of relying on expensive pre-packaged options, Natura allows restaurants to transform tap water into premium sparkling water instantly—reducing overhead while enhancing service. For operators who choose to charge, this creates a major advantage: lower costs = more competitive pricing = better guest acceptance. Final Thoughts Charging for sparkling water in 2026 isn’t about right or wrong—it’s about execution. When done thoughtfully, it can: Enhance the dining experience Support profitability Align with sustainability goals But when handled poorly, it risks damaging guest trust. The future of water service isn’t just premium—it’s intentional, transparent, and experience-driven . To learn more about our water systems and how we can help improve revenue for your business, please schedule a meeting today!
Why Triple-Filtered Water Tastes Better Than Reverse Osmosis | Natura Water
March 6, 2026
Learn why Natura Water’s triple-filtered water tastes better than reverse osmosis. Our ANSI 42, 53, and 61 certified filtration removes contaminants while preserving clean, refreshing taste.
January 5, 2026
Discover how Natura Water helps organizations achieve 2026 sustainability goals by replacing bottled water with cost-effective, on-site water systems.
September 19, 2025
Natura Water Limited Lease Event
August 19, 2025
What Sets Natura Water Apart from the Competition
Show More

Share Link